Repository navigation
Selected packing: all 21,886 cross-call 0,1,7 to 0,0,8 cycles fail timing - #2145
Merged
Mister-Meeseeks merged 1 commit intoOct 15, 2026
Merged
Conversation
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Result
On the original selected PR 1094 owner map, no simultaneous cross-call
three-role cycle among distinct occupied bins can coalesce idle ranks
{0,1,7}->{0,0,8}with the existing event windows. Complete finite domain:21,886 capacity-feasible cycles, all window-blocked. No new supplier or κ.
This takes one bounded slice of PR 1873's open cross-call continuation. It
does not repeat the known sequential neutral-then-strict relocation census
or claim to close all three-role exchanges.
Exact obstruction
The complete source type prefilter supports only:
(slack,width)(7,8),(0,8),(1,7)(255,430)(7,8),(1,7),(0,7)(-1,208)The sole
(7,8)role is(stage,replica,helper)=(7,14,296), bin(13,15,14);the sole
(1,7)role is(1,15,226), bin(11,8,103). Their fixed timingsreject each whole row independently of the third role. The exclusion holds
even with active-pair and family restrictions relaxed. The favorable idle
delta
-H1-H7+H8would lower the complete fixed-word moment for all0<a<1bystrict concavity if legal; none of these candidates is legal.
Assignment, provenance and coordination
math, implementation, documentation and separate read-only AI review.
3474c3e21150f5db2b291dfc2989aac6; catalogue key2eb6f6918b10e182033b; priority revision 4.0fdd7d82de03e43c9e5a1000dfbcd380d1b687d2;selected supplier head
0fc329d0bec93ca7cd288eaea1295172e8789810.Selected PR1094: exact single whole-helper relocation census #1332 (comment).
selected record are retained as historical provenance. No source copies,
predecessor edits, selected-record changes or dependency installation.
instruction/catalogue/priority/selected/source compatibility diff empty.
complete pagination at 2026-10-14T20:41:25Z, plus local notes/ledger. No
competing exact slice found; no novelty guarantee.
Nearest owning sources retain credit:
#1873
(
08f1eaf5946f57de0e126e82b5e0432564cca4e0, same-call three-cycles),#1790
(
48ee04ee708081c8713e8868a370bbbf5aa099e1, two-role swaps),#1617
(
536bc90ea2de310e0e08d2cb65f7add1d9de92b5, complete sequential two-relocationcensus), #1407
(
d8640f5b7ae99b43f5d56146cb94ca62b8b3835d, longer sequential paths), and#1154
(
390de2866a03758e7f4ddbb2846e5b2ee4e72154, positive cycle on a different word/map).Evidence and verification
Adds only
research/selected-crosscall-rank8-cycle/: README, TASK, SOURCES,VERIFY, RESULT, verify.py, test_verify.py.
Primary type-count/indexed join and separate role-first direct enumeration
agree on all 21,886 candidates and zero all-window-pass landings. The latter
does not call the primary transfer or landing predicate. Both methods share
source decoding and PR 1091 geometry, explicitly disclosed. Constant-block
objects and a digest of the complete direct candidate-ID list are retained.
Acceptance regenerates the census, not a hash-only assertion.
Controls: six synthetic toy checks, eleven unchanged PR 1091 owner mutations,
omitted-count and int/float receipt rejections, a rank-key serialization
round-trip/int-float/int-Boolean regression, and rejected over-budget runs
on blocked first landings or empty input. No real attaining cycle or
modified-map admission is claimed. All registered commands run optimized.
Both complete pinned supplier profiles are repriced with exact rational
intervals: selected endpoints pass, next
10^-24ticks fail; bit's inherited10^-16envelope of32*m^2rank-one fallback calls per paid child is included.Complex remains binding.
ceiling(local,73,896,9,64)reproducesa<0.001690054109089, balanced planning capκ<0.001687202646;0% of packing headroom realized. PR 1847's tighter fixed-route ceiling is
also credited in the README, not newly replayed or claimed sharp.
Local Windows/Python3.12 output:
Separate read-only AI review independently rebuilt raw source geometry,
all supported types and all 21,886 candidate IDs, confirmed both constant
window blocks and exact prices, and passed a 200-case family/cache differential
check. Its deadline-bypass finding was reproduced by a failing test and fixed
with guards covering setup, skipped branches and completion; the same reviewer
reran the original bypass and confirmed rejection. No unresolved issue remained
in that targeted follow-up.
No hosted CI success, independent human review or formal-kernel execution is
claimed. No native/controller/invoice/outer/full cold replay was run. Scalar
word, all widths/calls/order, actual windows and prefix model are held fixed.
All inherited all-size/compiler, realization, hosting, precision/tape,
analytic and bit H1–H5 obligations remain open/inherited.
Handoff and credit
The larger cross-call three-cycle domain remains open. A bounded next step is to
classify another supported transition touching a slack-7 bin, including old
slacks involving rank 3, before joining exact windows/families. Three-component
transitions need not be majorization-ordered; the simple pairwise sign rule
is not sufficient. Structured next question is in TASK/README.
Rohan Arun/PR 1094; retained Jeremy Kothe mutable-leaver/Hao Yan controller
lineage; Josie Elliston/PR 1091 owner audit; PR1790/PR 1873 and cited relocation
work; Douglas Colkitt/PR 1240 ceiling; PR 1012 coverage; PR 1847 fixed-route
context; PR 589/PR 555 and retained bit lineage. Apache-2.0.
Workflow feedback: the live overlap check prevented repeating the saturated
neutral-relocation domain. The useful certificate is two constant timing
inequalities, not a large search archive. Receipt replay exposed numeric-rank
JSON key ordering; a failing regression led to normalization of keys before
sorting, while int/float and int/Boolean values remain distinct. The review
also caught a rejected-landing path that bypassed the deadline check; the
stop rule is now covered by a deterministic regression. Temporary
worktree cleanup follows publication at the donor's request.