You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
CMake and Meson build definitions are Out Of Sync #894
The CMake and Meson build definitions are maintained separately and have drifted. On current main (e0399c6945326dd5281da07de8ed14a61c9f2cac), equivalent configurations do not install the same public headers or run the same core tests.
Examples:
CMake installs public headers by globbing each directory, while Meson lists them manually. As a result:
CMake installs iceberg/puffin_dv_io.h and iceberg/catalog/rest/auth/token_refresh_scheduler.h, but Meson does not.
Meson installs iceberg/catalog/catalog_util.h, iceberg/catalog/session_catalog.h, and iceberg/catalog/session_context.h, but CMake does not install headers from src/iceberg/catalog/.
CMake includes snapshot_summary_builder_test.cc in table_test, but Meson does not include that test source, so the Meson CI path does not exercise it.
Vendored/fallback dependency versions differ between the two build systems:
Dependency
CMake
Meson
CRoaring
4.4.3
4.3.11
nlohmann/json
3.11.3
3.12.0
GoogleTest
1.15.2
1.17.0
Other shared dependencies, such as nanoarrow 0.9.0, utf8proc 2.10.0, spdlog 1.15.3, cpr 1.14.1, and Google Benchmark 1.8.4, are currently aligned but can drift because their pins are also declared independently.
Dependency resolution policy also differs: CMake requires system Zlib and Curl, while Meson can fall back to pinned wraps (Zlib 1.3.1 and Curl 8.10.1). Any intentional difference here should be documented and tested explicitly.
The Meson bundle gap is already tracked by #256 and is outside the scope of this issue. Other intentional feature differences should likewise remain explicit rather than appearing as accidental drift.
This to track current status and initiated a discussion on how we can maintain and sync the build tools in the long term.
Hi! I'd like to take this issue. Could a committer please assign it to me? My plan is to diff the CMake and Meson definitions, reconcile the options/targets, and add a CI check that keeps the two in sync. Thanks!
We should consider dropping Meson support if no one uses or actively maintains it. I believe AI coding tools can keep the Meson build files in sync with CMake, but that doesn't seem to be the case in practice :(
Activity
Adarsh-Me commentedon Sep 2, 2026
Hi! I'd like to take this issue. Could a committer please assign it to me? My plan is to diff the CMake and Meson definitions, reconcile the options/targets, and add a CI check that keeps the two in sync. Thanks!
[-]Keep CMake and Meson build definitions in sync[/-][+]CMake and Meson build definitions are Out Of Sync[/+]zhjwpku commentedon Sep 5, 2026
We should consider dropping Meson support if no one uses or actively maintains it. I believe AI coding tools can keep the Meson build files in sync with CMake, but that doesn't seem to be the case in practice :(